First time here? Sign up for a free account or log in

Forums » Branding/Packaging » Topic


How many g7's on Hammacher Schlemmer?
bobcat's Avatar
steven helline
bobcat

Hello,

My first time posting and submitting. I was curious how many people are at g7 with hs. I feel pretty fortunate, considering it’s my first submission. How ever, I’ve got 7 years of blood, sweat, rejection, elation, disapointment, yes’s, no’s, i suck, it’s great, i’d buy one, nope go fish, you ought to do this,……yadayadayadaaaaaa. Probably, alot of you can identify with this?…..uh??
posted May 19, 2009 15:55 (
)

Posting replies has been disabled
badone1965's Avatar
robert of Wv
badone1965

if you have this much time in it why are you here>?

i mean you`ve done 90% of the work and now you want to lose most of your profits , why?

i would continue on my own, the payoff is gonna be better.

also why did you post the same thread twice?

well good luck with your idea

posted May 19, 2009 16:33 (
)
bobcat's Avatar
steven helline
bobcat
I accidently posted twice. I didn’t think branding was the right place for this. You bring up some great points. I’m at a point where I’m out of money, I’ve invested 20k. I need another 16k to start the asian market with not knowing how enforceable a contract would be with them. I do have an opportunity though. I have a full time job ( as do 95%) of the people here. To do the importing, warehousing, advertising, distribution, accounting ect…I don’t have the time and frankly, just tired of all the bs. at this point, I just want SOMETHING. I’ve tried knocking on doors and had some close deals but all I got was close. I maybe short changing, I’m not sure if I can opt out at this time anyhow….my gut tells me to go with my deal in china….the problem is, once it appears there, it will get knocked off and beat me to the US market. I may not be getting a patent……So it’s a race. in my book. My brain is just mush right now with all the work, time and money invested. My wife’s gettin’ tired of hearing how I ’ve “really” found someone to help us this time and not have it pan out.

PLEASE, please, please give me some more insight and your opinion, the vodca doesn’t cut it anymore….

posted May 19, 2009 17:03 (
)
badone1965's Avatar
robert of Wv
badone1965

Roger Brown or Mark Reynolds is most likely your best bet for good info and no B.S
contact one of them

posted May 19, 2009 17:52 (
)
toni's Avatarg8_badge
Toni LaCava
toni
193,750
Insider Points

I would only suggest Mr.Roger Brown.

Mr. Helline what state do you live in?

posted May 19, 2009 18:05 (
)
mginjhw's Avatarg8_badge
Mike G
mginjhw

Hi Steven, if you’re at the G7 stage, you’re committed to EN and HS until you’re either given a licensing contract or they reject it. If you’re this far, I’d hang through the process and if HS doesn’t want it you’ve still got all your options after that.

posted May 19, 2009 18:11 (
)
bobcat's Avatar
steven helline
bobcat

thanks Tony Joe, Mike

I live in Ohio. I guess all I can do is see what happens. Thanks for the input.
posted May 19, 2009 18:23 (
)
badone1965's Avatar
robert of Wv
badone1965

Mike

one other thing i think you forgot,

correct me if i`m wrong…if your idea is shown to HS it is tied up for 6months after that correct??

posted May 19, 2009 18:39 (
)
dean's Avatar
Dean Chatfield
dean

Steven,

Well done on the HS G7. I’m hanging in there also. Maybe it’s Ohio’s turn! Go Cavs (also)!!!

Dean

posted May 19, 2009 18:41 (
)
hollyshoe's Avataree_badge
Holly Tucker
hollyshoe

It’s only tied up while at G7 or G8. Once it goes R8, it is released immediately.

posted May 19, 2009 18:44 (
)
badone1965's Avatar
robert of Wv
badone1965

holly

i was under the impression that if it was shown to the company that it was tied up for 6 months incase they change their mind.
you are most likely right.
by the way congrats to you.

posted May 19, 2009 18:47 (
)
toni's Avatarg8_badge
Toni LaCava
toni
193,750
Insider Points

Holly is correct.:)

posted May 19, 2009 18:49 (
)
badone1965's Avatar
robert of Wv
badone1965

toni

i knew i was wrong. man i hate that lol. time to eat more crow yum yum

posted May 19, 2009 18:54 (
)
bobcat's Avatar
steven helline
bobcat

hello!

I’m fortunate to still be in on a g7 in hs….has anyone heard anything or know how many finalists there may be?

thanks

posted May 29, 2009 06:15 (
)
duffyg43's Avatar
Maria Gale
duffyg43

Hi,
Yes they had 40 Finalists at Edison, out of those 40, 11 were chosen to go on to HS for their final choice. I was cut at 5 but my Best Friend is one of the 11 who has moved on to HS. They could choose 1,or all of them. She is thrilled since she has had blood sweat and money poured into her product. It is out of Edisons hands now I believe.

posted May 29, 2009 21:12 (
)
badone1965's Avatar
robert of Wv
badone1965

maria

if your friend has alot money into her idea why did she submit it to EN??
the 2500.00 is the best part of the search. short of that the way the contract is you may not make alot . unless your idea is the next big hit.

posted May 29, 2009 21:16 (
)
duffyg43's Avatar
Maria Gale
duffyg43

Good Question! She is a widow and works and Mom who has spent so much (ten thousand plus) on the graphics and prototypes. I have two Provisional Patents and Trademarks and she knows the expense involved. She was tapped out, plus rejections. The great thing about the Internet, and I hope you all share this, if her project is chosen and published online and in the HS Magazine which we all take and read on flights, I am going to set her up with her own website to advertise online for under 100.00 a month. That will present her product to everyone and where they can purchase it. She can pick area codes, it will be on Facebook, Google, Twitter etc., and for that price she has presented her own product that someone else has produced marketed insured and shipped. Then it becomes the NEXT BIG HIT!
If that opens the door for her to have freedom to devote her ALL to become a full time product designer, I am thrilled she went this far!!!

posted May 29, 2009 21:53 (
)
duffyg43's Avatar
Maria Gale
duffyg43

PS. I will pay for her advertising. I believe in her that much!!! If we are here we all have a yearning to succeed!

posted May 29, 2009 21:56 (
)
bobcat's Avatar
steven helline
bobcat

maria,

Thanks for your reply….can you tell me where do you found out how many finalists exist for these searches?

thanks, steve

posted May 30, 2009 07:04 (
)
ivanna's Avatar
Irina Ivanna
ivanna

Robert, not everyone has guts/money/support/health/emotions/abilities/knowledge/you-name-it to continue the process of bringing a product up to the market, once it started. We can start fresh and full of hopes, but give up after so many outbreaks. It is a situation when you still believe in your idea but running empty, and then finding such place as EN feels like you are finally in safe and pleasant land of Hope, where you can take a couple of breathes and recuperate from the stress.

posted May 30, 2009 07:12 (
)
ivanna's Avatar
Irina Ivanna
ivanna

Steven, I do believe that hardly anyone can give you the exat numbers of what is happening out there behind that door.
Congrats on your G7!

posted May 30, 2009 07:18 (
)
bobcat's Avatar
steven helline
bobcat

Robert,

I know you questioned me on why I’m here at en with so much invested. It made me look into the compensation deal you get awarded and it’s not bad. I believe outside of en licensing agreements are typically structured close to 7-10% of wholesale sell price after costs. ( not cost of production) but more administrative, advertising, returns, ect…. EN in my eyes is a fair deal. I’ve worked my *ss off for 7 years…….it is difficult and not for the timid to go it alone. For instance, for $25.00 EN evaluates, preliminary patent search, market analysis, price point and lines you up with a company that is willing to purchase your idea. They did in 3 months what took me 7 yrs. Maybe I’m a slow learner. But doing it alone takes boat loads of time and money. Not to mention weeding out the people and/ or companies that don’t have your best interests in mind that just string you along milking you like a brown jersey cow. My point being, for them to to what they do and still offer a competitive compensation as a individual deal may be….kudo’s to them. I hope I’m not coming across confrontational-that’s not my intent and I apologize if I do. I just think that EN is probably the best resource for us inventors that don’t have the time, money and most important, the connections to take a product from concept to market.
posted May 30, 2009 07:55 (
)
daisykat's Avatargold
Carol S
daisykat
114,750
Insider Points

Steven, John Meacham usually posts all of the announcements about the various presentations on the thread: Official Q & A for Live Product Search. This is where he mentioned how many were presented and how many were still in the running. That is also the thread he watches for questions as it is an official EN thread.

Hope this helps!

posted May 30, 2009 08:39 (
)
badone1965's Avatar
robert of Wv
badone1965

steven

i understand what you are saying…for many years i`ve had ideas with nothing to do with them only to watch them come to market years later.
i was just thinking you`ve got alot of money into this and seems you`ve done 90%of the work already
EN offers a great deal for 25.00 but i

posted May 30, 2009 16:50 (
)
txyellarose's Avatar
Lesia InTexas
txyellarose

Steven,

I agree with one thing…people can sit on a product for years…And spend thousands getting it ready for someone to HOPEFULLY be willing to give you a licensing deal…The thing I have learned by doing some research is that a lot of expenses that companies are charging people for, were things I can eventually do myself…

My husband came up with a great idea about 12 years ago…We contacted an invention company….Turns out “It was a Rip Off”…They only wanted us to remortgage our home to pay their fees….Not happening….So we got frustrated and gave up our ideas all together there for awhile…

But as years went on I realized…We have some great ideas just wasting away in a notebook…So I started right here on my research journey…I have met people…Learned things that will help me get a lot farther than I ever imagined…Most of the things I was being charged for, are things I can do myself…Good Luck….Never give up!!

posted May 30, 2009 18:01 (
)
silaikas's Avatar
Scott Silaika
silaikas

Hi everyone

Looks like I am one of the “11” Maria mentioned and HS has my proto for evaluation. Very exciting. My idea is pretty advanced, a few tweaks for production, and they could have manufactured units in couple months.

During the past three years with this project I have learned a lot, and still believe EE is the best way to get product on the market. A wise friend I met along the journey has seen many good products that suffered from lack of funds to advertise & market. These costs can run 5 – 10x more than development, so if your struggling to pay for patents, trademarks, incorporating, engineering, etc, going to market alone is very risky.

posted June 01, 2009 05:48 (
)
bobcat's Avatar
steven helline
bobcat

hey scott,

I wish you good luck! I too have a factory made prototype w/ all the cad files ready for production. I too found the marketing/distribution side to be the most difficult. Congrats on making it this far!!
posted June 01, 2009 06:06 (
)
smoketree345's Avatar
George Keith
smoketree345

Has any one won Hamacher contest?

posted October 28, 2009 10:55 (
)
silaikas's Avatar
Scott Silaika
silaikas

My G7 got rejected, and I remain dissapointed with this process. Seems like all EN wants is that 10 bucks a month. Thousands of inventors with very few successes. And what about season 4?

posted November 03, 2009 12:37 (
)
marlasball's Avatar
Marla Ball
marlasball

Hello Scott,

Sorry about your disappointment and I hope that you continue to participate in searches. Today I announced 4 inventors whose inventions were selected through Live Product Searches, and yesterday I announced 2, so there are plenty of success stories. Please also note that you do not have to pay $10 a month, Gold Membership is optional.

Season 3 of Everyday Edisons is scheduled to air next year, and casting calls will follow. As soon as we secure the cities and dates we will announce them right here on the Edison Nation website.

Thanks

posted November 03, 2009 13:22 (
)
Posting replies has been disabled

« Return to the forums index page