First time here? Sign up for a free account or log in

Forums » Creativity » Topic


Part of my design is now used by a company I submitted my product to.
joyg's Avatar
Joyce Gomez
joyg

My hair accessory organizer has a tube to hold headbands. I consider this to be the most unique part of my invention. It was a simple idea, yet no one provided storage for headbands with a tube.

I submitted my product, Ultimate Hair Accessory Organizer, to Goody a few years ago. I was told my product was discussed and they felt it was too large for their expensive retail space.

A few weeks ago, walking through Target, guess what I see? A tube attached to the wall with headbands on it. They are using the tube design to sell their headbands. It looks great! I can’t help but think, someone at that meeting liked my idea of providing a simple tube to hold headbands.

I’m guessing Goody will begin getting request for such holders. Then they’ll have to claim it was their idea to create an organizer that is similar to mine.

I’m not upset with this. I just wanted to explain the look on my face and how I felt when I realized it was Goody that did this. It was a funny feeling and the wide open mouth expression!

Best wishes to all,
Joyce
www.DesignsByJoyG.com

posted September 07, 2009 20:13 (
)

Posting replies has been disabled
boxerballsbrendan's Avatar
brendan reen
boxerballsbrendan

i know what you mean, and when companies boast about what brilliant in-house designers they have!! this inventing business can leave some people feeling cheated.

posted September 08, 2009 04:15 (
)
boxerballsbrendan's Avatar
brendan reen
boxerballsbrendan

I am even more tolerent of street muggers since I started inventing, they are pretty upfront people those street muggers, they do not pretend to be anything more than what they are.

posted September 08, 2009 04:19 (
)
joseph's Avatargold
joseph jackson
joseph
64,750
Insider Points

Joyce Hi,

this is why we should love everybody and trust no one when it comes to inventing.

posted September 08, 2009 05:55 (
)
sleepyhead's Avatar
Julie Brown
sleepyhead

Joyce, Years ago at the Yankee Inventors Expo I met a sales rep for primarily hair products: she is in NY and is always interested in new products and might even have manufacturing connections. If you would like to explore this avenue, let me know and I will find her name and number for you.

Good luck and I’m amazed that you aren’t upset: guess that imitation is the greatest form of flattery – but I would be miffed.

posted September 08, 2009 07:07 (
)
eva's Avatargold
eva winger
eva
50,000
Insider Points

hi joyce!

just popping in to say hi!

i love following my fellow inventor’s stories…

would love to catch up sometime

e.

posted September 08, 2009 14:37 (
)
joyg's Avatar
Joyce Gomez
joyg

Hi Brendan, Joseph, and Julie,

I love your comments! Julie, any information is welcomed to getting my product out of my hands.

Hey Eva, looks like we’re part of the “oldies but goodies” group. not the “GOODY” group!!! So many new faces here and the originals have slowly gone away. I enjoy popping in too to follow the interesting forums. It’s good seeing you, we’ll catch up soon.

Joyce

posted September 08, 2009 19:02 (
)
sleepyhead's Avatar
Julie Brown
sleepyhead

Hi Joyce, I just e-mailed the woman’s name and her website and hope that this connection will work for you.

posted September 08, 2009 20:14 (
)
joyg's Avatar
Joyce Gomez
joyg

Hi Julie,

Thanks for the e-mail. I had a feeling that was who you knew from N.Y. She was a member here, and there was a little trouble with her using the EN site over a year ago. I contacted her back then and got the “unfavorable” response:(

Thanks,
Joyce

posted September 08, 2009 20:41 (
)
boxerballsbrendan's Avatar
brendan reen
boxerballsbrendan

From John Steinbeck’s Novel, East of Eden published in 1952: I think it was. The man in the story was a farmer who was constantly inventing and trying to make money from his inventions, but as Steinbeck’s says in the book of Samuel (the inventor)
--‘He developed a very bad patent habit, a disease many men suffer from’
‘Samuel sent his models to a manufacturer, who promptly rejected the plans and used the method’.——- -

That was in the beginning of the last century at least I think, so nothing really changes 100 years or so later
So take courage all, we are not alone in our experiences.

posted September 09, 2009 02:26 (
)
boxerballsbrendan's Avatar
brendan reen
boxerballsbrendan

He neglected to mention women suffer from it as well though.

posted September 09, 2009 02:28 (
)
sleepyhead's Avatar
Julie Brown
sleepyhead

Hi Joyce, Sorry that it wasn’t a good lead. I should have used the little search button above and then I would have known that you already knew of her. She has helped many but she is really one tough cookie: not sure what her interest in the pillowcase was.

Good luck in your quest…..

posted September 09, 2009 08:55 (
)
joyg's Avatar
Joyce Gomez
joyg

Hi Julie,

I found your product, it’s all over the internet! Great idea!

posted September 09, 2009 14:43 (
)
joyg's Avatar
Joyce Gomez
joyg

Hi Brendan,

I watched your video, cool product! I can see it in fun colors sold in a toy store too. What fun!!!!!

posted September 09, 2009 14:46 (
)
cattycatranch's Avatar
Linda Linda
cattycatranch

Brendan, I was joking when I called the “inventing obsession” an illness. Didn’t know John Steinbeck also did so, although he was serious. Interesting. If there was a drug to cure our condition, would you take it?

posted September 09, 2009 16:49 (
)
sillysue's Avatar
Susan E.
sillysue

What is your product, Julie? I checked your profile and didn’t see a mention of it.

posted September 09, 2009 20:52 (
)
sleepyhead's Avatar
Julie Brown
sleepyhead

Hi Susan, www.e-zzzsleep.com is what I entered in BB&B but would also ‘give’ them www.sleepyheadpillowcase.com. I’ll put it on my profile because I also have another product – totally unrelated.

posted September 09, 2009 20:56 (
)
boxerballsbrendan's Avatar
brendan reen
boxerballsbrendan

Thanks Joyce for the encouragement, it helps a lot..
To lindas question would I take a pill to stop inventing.
no- I would not. modern society jobs often treat people like machuines.
It is my outlet for creativity- more natural. Prehistoric humans were constantly trying to think up ways of, how do I cross the river? how do I trap the hog? how can I keep out the cold better?
(sorry to the animal lovers, not a hunter myself, just saying)

posted September 10, 2009 01:54 (
)
boxerballsbrendan's Avatar
brendan reen
boxerballsbrendan

I have just figured out why men wear shirt and ties, subconciously it represents success, the successful hunter came home with a animal over his shoulders, around his neck and the head and neck draped down the front,Like a primate tie, I am a genius!! or am I mad??

posted September 10, 2009 01:58 (
)
cattycatranch's Avatar
Linda Linda
cattycatranch

A bloody primate tie??

Brendan, you ask: I am a genius!! or am I mad??

Howabout a mad genius?

(;^)

posted September 10, 2009 04:18 (
)
boxerballsbrendan's Avatar
brendan reen
boxerballsbrendan

I know a bloody tie?? i love the way you put that.
but our image of success has got hooked on this silly thing draped around the neck, fashions change but the tie survives it has no know purpose
other than you could be trottled in bar brawl if you wore one.

posted September 10, 2009 11:30 (
)
sleepyhead's Avatar
Julie Brown
sleepyhead

I don’t know, Brendan, I like the ties. In nature, it is the male which has the color, in life, it is the women who have make-up and necklaces, bracelets, earrings, etc. so the men need something – I think.

posted September 10, 2009 11:48 (
)
boxerballsbrendan's Avatar
brendan reen
boxerballsbrendan

ok ok but only a clip on one so

posted September 10, 2009 11:55 (
)
sillysue's Avatar
Susan E.
sillysue

Thanks for sending your web addresss to me, Julie. You have some nice products!

From my experience, a “tube” isn’t unique when it comes to displaying head bands. I remember hollow, cylindrical displays for head bands when I worked as a store sales clerk in the 80s. I’ve seen them in many accessory stores since that time. I’ve also seen upright “tubes” that you can display headbands on and use the interior for holding and displaying other items like hair scrunchies.

If you Google “head band display” and look at the image results, you’ll see several tube-like holders.

What kind of patent protection do you have for your design?

posted September 10, 2009 18:19 (
)
pepperit's Avatar
Pepper Evans
pepperit

Talk about ignoring the intellectual property law. You can sue the company for what they did. It’s for this reason that I prefer apparel trade shows whenever I have new pieces to display because private companies have the reputation of stealing other people’s ideas.

posted September 18, 2009 17:53 (
)
mger80's Avatargold
Margaret Pryor
mger80
215,500
Insider Points

I don’t believe she could sue. She has a design patent and I don’t believe a design patent covers components of the design, but the overall design itself. The tube is only a part of the design of Joyce’s product. And as Susan said, the tube is not unique. Although I think it is new to the consumer, I believe the commercial market has used tubes in this way for many years. The way she put the organizer together is unique, but not the tube itself.

posted September 19, 2009 11:03 (
)
mopar78's Avatar
Ronald Pickle
mopar78

How unfortunate… It happens all the time…

posted September 19, 2009 11:13 (
)
Posting replies has been disabled

« Return to the forums index page