First time here? Sign up for a free account or log in

Forums » Live Product Search » Topic


SkyMall Challenge
klangdon's Avataren_staff_badge
Kim Langdon
Insider Points

Do you have an idea that could be the next must-have SkyMall product but lack the resources to develop it? Then this challenge is for you!

To learn more and/or to submit your idea check out this link: http://www.edisonnation.com/live_product_search...

Happy Inventing!

posted September 28, 2011 13:02 (
)


ginja's Avatargold
ginger valentino-virga
163,500
Insider Points

R4 – there is movement – just not in the right direction! Had thought this one was a really great fit too. Oh well have one left in play for this.

posted May 16, 2012 10:55 (
)
zabber's Avatargold
Andrea Zabinski
742,000
Insider Points

Awesome Scott that clears it up! Makes a ton of sense…

posted May 15, 2012 08:14 (
)
laura1003's Avatargold
Laura Anderson
73,000
Insider Points

Okey Dokey, Thanks Scott! :-)

posted May 15, 2012 07:55 (
)
sgdromms's Avataren_staff_badge
Scott Dromms
Insider Points

protection and the ability to possibly protect are always looked at in every item that anyone considers trying to market, but not always the deciding factor.

Have to remember catalog is a unique business as the ability to WOW someone quickly with a picture and make them connect to the item is a challenge…especially if you are flying on a plane and were up really early !!

So wouldn’t say it was a requirement for Skymall, but as always something to consider. The ability to protect an item is a chief consideration for many companies, but not sole factor.

Presentation date June 7th as they had some folks that were not able to attend May 31st due to schedule changes on their end.

posted May 15, 2012 07:52 (
)
zabber's Avatargold
Andrea Zabinski
742,000
Insider Points

Sorry Laura, the one that is G6 for skymall does have a PPA on it, you might be right??

posted May 15, 2012 07:46 (
)
laura1003's Avatargold
Laura Anderson
73,000
Insider Points

2 R-4s. I think they were favoring some type of protection on these. Anyway, Good Luck to everyone and have a Beautiful Day! :D

posted May 15, 2012 07:10 (
)
kmsinvention's Avatargold
Kara Morgan
21,500
Insider Points

Yeah, I gotta grow thicker skin i guess, lol.

Happy Mother’s Day to all the mommies out there!

posted May 12, 2012 23:55 (
)
zabber's Avatargold
Andrea Zabinski
742,000
Insider Points

Kara you need a MEDIC!! LOL…rough one for all! That’s a holiday weekend so I am not surpriced they postponed! Good luck to those still in!

posted May 12, 2012 04:29 (
)
ginja's Avatargold
ginger valentino-virga
163,500
Insider Points

Have a couple stuck at G3 for a long time now. Maybe they pushed back presentation to catch up. Other then those I got two R4 and two R5. I think this will be a hard search to get one to go G7 for presentation

posted May 11, 2012 15:53 (
)
kmsinvention's Avatargold
Kara Morgan
21,500
Insider Points

All 6 of mine are now R5. This one’s a gusher, stop the bleeding!!!

posted May 11, 2012 11:25 (
)
laura1003's Avatargold
Laura Anderson
73,000
Insider Points

Presentation got moved to June 7th :)

posted May 11, 2012 10:21 (
)
inventormom's Avatargold
patricia herzog-mesrobian
344,250
Insider Points

Actually I am feeling pretty guilty about this .guys … After I mentioned Snapware early this am .. everything sorta went south for me as well .. R5 along with many others here at the Mall !! .. … Opps !!! Sometimes rattling the cage does more than just stirr up the dust !!!

posted May 10, 2012 17:39 (
)
zabber's Avatargold
Andrea Zabinski
742,000
Insider Points

Sorry about the R’s guys, I think this one was the hardest by far, I wonder if they had criteria for this one? MMMM…scratching head…

posted May 10, 2012 17:03 (
)
dolikedogdo01's Avatargold
Jay Alger
47,500
Insider Points

Feeling the pain Willy G. James X5 here also :(

posted May 10, 2012 16:27 (
)
o2b1's Avatargold
William G. James
20,750
Insider Points

Bah! Humbugs! X5…

posted May 10, 2012 12:20 (
)
zabber's Avatargold
Andrea Zabinski
742,000
Insider Points

I take that back its on MAY 31st!!! WOW!!

posted May 10, 2012 11:56 (
)
zabber's Avatargold
Andrea Zabinski
742,000
Insider Points

Yikes, this one is hard it seems, I still have 2 G5’s and 1 G6 in the mix…moving slow, wonder when this will happen?

posted May 10, 2012 11:55 (
)
kdulan's Avatargold
Kyle Dulan
99,500
Insider Points

I’m with you Margaret. 1 R4 and 2 R5’s knocked me out in one fail swoop. Good luck to everyone still in.

posted May 10, 2012 11:32 (
)
mger80's Avatargold
Margaret Pryor
277,500
Insider Points

R5. I’m out of this one. Good luck everyone!

posted May 10, 2012 10:27 (
)
kmsinvention's Avatargold
Kara Morgan
21,500
Insider Points

Thanks Fred…I can take it though. I’m just glad they did it quickly so I wasn’t sitting around for months waiting. I prefer the old “pull off the band-aid” approach in this case :).

posted May 07, 2012 21:50 (
)
wherritt's Avatargold
Fred Wherritt
74,250
Insider Points

Sorry Kara, that is a lot of Red all at once. Congrats on the G5

posted May 07, 2012 14:44 (
)
kmsinvention's Avatargold
Kara Morgan
21,500
Insider Points

They seem to be making some moves in this latest challenge, unfortunately, not in my favour. I just got FOUR – yes 4 R4’s. That really stung…..But I also got an G5 in the Franco Manufacturing search, yeah!

posted May 07, 2012 10:55 (
)
raandre's Avatar
Richard Andre

I am a newbie and have a question on this. SkyMall has a huge range of products it sells but it doesn’t produce these things. A product would be made by a manufacturer. So how would this work? If SkyMall likes a product, EN would have to deal with a manufacturer who would make the product and it might be licensed to the manufacturer not SkyMall, right? It doesn’t appear that SkyMall has any exclusivity to the products it sells. Just curious how things go here .

posted May 06, 2012 08:38 (
)
laura1003's Avatargold
Laura Anderson
73,000
Insider Points

Bumpity bump bump, ;-) Any movement on this one, I’ve got 2 at G3. Presentation is coming at the end of the month. I see th DJ search is on the 14th.

posted May 04, 2012 11:13 (
)
eddie_szumski's Avatargold
Edward Szumski
37,500
Insider Points

same j.b!

posted April 25, 2012 19:02 (
)
ideamation's Avatar
Input 100% Return 5%

I am looking for a splash of color to my dashboard it’s about that time of the season again!

posted April 25, 2012 08:36 (
)
kdulan's Avatargold
Kyle Dulan
99,500
Insider Points

Sorry to hear about the R’s Todd and Margaret. I have had my share in this search also. I still have 1 G2 and 2 G4’s in yet. As much as I like movement, I like having green on my dash more…

posted April 24, 2012 14:17 (
)
wherritt's Avatargold
Fred Wherritt
74,250
Insider Points

Sorry Margaret for the R’s. I hope the G’s go all the way. You are due for some more G7’s and of course the elusive G8.

posted April 24, 2012 13:56 (
)
mger80's Avatargold
Margaret Pryor
277,500
Insider Points

2 R5’s. Still have two more ideas hanging at G4 and G2 though.

posted April 24, 2012 13:11 (
)
rackaball's Avatargold
Fred Locke
11,000
Insider Points

You will get em next time Todd. Sorry to hear.
I am still hopeful. Just passed the “Research & Development” stage and in the “Final Consideration” stage. Got my fingers crossed for sure!
Good luck to everyone!

posted April 20, 2012 15:18 (
)
statgear37's Avatargold
Avi Goldstein
40,000
Insider Points

Don’t get discouraged Todd! If it’s a good idea it just may not be a fit with these specific manufacturers. keep searchin!

posted April 20, 2012 14:36 (
)
benco's Avatargold
Ben Cohen
40,000
Insider Points

I didn’t submit to this search, but I feel your pain. Red is no bueno.

posted April 19, 2012 18:58 (
)
zabber's Avatargold
Andrea Zabinski
742,000
Insider Points

MEDIC!!!

posted April 19, 2012 18:38 (
)
southerngirl's Avatargold
Annette Umphlett
30,000
Insider Points

Todd…..Sorry to hear that! I’m stuck at G3. Don’t want an R!!!!!!

posted April 19, 2012 17:19 (
)
zabber's Avatargold
Andrea Zabinski
742,000
Insider Points

Todd, sorry…never easy…lot’s of R’s going around…I heard…

posted April 19, 2012 16:11 (
)
brainstream's Avatargold
Todd Pagel
78,000
Insider Points

Arghhhh…Crappy day today. R7 in Rexon and now an R5 in Skymall. Checking my dashboard…We got a bleeder over here! Red everywhere. ;-O

posted April 19, 2012 14:20 (
)
zabber's Avatargold
Andrea Zabinski
742,000
Insider Points

Thanks Carlos, you are a sweetie…I see a date!! May 31st, so that’s great! Good luck everyone, this one is sooo fun, but will be hard to get a G7!

posted April 18, 2012 18:38 (
)
carlitosway's Avatar
carlos romo
122,250
Insider Points

Way to go Andrea, you deserve it…you been sooooo close many times, and I think you have the most points then anybody…lol I think it’s your time to shine..congrats for your G6!!

posted April 12, 2012 20:50 (
)
wherritt's Avatargold
Fred Wherritt
74,250
Insider Points

Welcome Fred and Avi. @Melinda, you are correct in that EN brought out a second search for Skymall on the heels of the first search.
This is not typically the way it goes (i have never seen it before), but I am sure they had their reasons. Good reasons I’m sure. Maybe Skymall just needed more product ideas in the pipeline and requested it, but that is just speculation. I wouldn’t let it prevent me from submitting to this second search. I am sure your idea will get the same attention as in any other search. Good luck!

posted April 12, 2012 16:05 (
)
momsmatter's Avatargold
melinda thompson
51,500
Insider Points

OK I am very confused. Do I have this right. They have not set a presentation for the search ending in January but they have another search getting ready to end in about a week? This does not sound right and why would EN allow a search to end when the sponsor has not even looked at the ideas from Jan? Or am I reading this thread incorrectly. I am just curiuos, I was getting ready to submit an idea to skymall. Thanks

posted April 12, 2012 15:31 (
)
statgear37's Avatargold
Avi Goldstein
40,000
Insider Points

Todd, My other product was not licensed. I use a contract manufacturer in the U.S and make it myself and sell it on my site as well as in bulk to major medical suppliers in the U.S. who then sell it to their distributors. Feel free to check it out. It’s on my site at statgeartools.com It’s the device which attaches medical tape to stethoscopes.

if you truly believe in your product then you can do the same. However, it is expensive and more risky. My current product is a lot more expensive to produce and may be a tough sell to retail chains not bec it’s not a great product idea but bec I have found that even with an awesome product, it’s soooo hard to get in touch with the right people. EN apparently has these connections and that’s why I’m hoping to license it rather than going about it myself this round!

posted April 12, 2012 15:30 (
)
rackaball's Avatargold
Fred Locke
11,000
Insider Points

I am in that one! Up to stage 3 and very hopeful

posted April 12, 2012 15:20 (
)
brainstream's Avatargold
Todd Pagel
78,000
Insider Points

Excellent, Avi. Want to share your previously licensed product with us? We love to see sucess stories!

posted April 12, 2012 15:16 (
)
statgear37's Avatargold
Avi Goldstein
40,000
Insider Points

Thanks Todd, Baruch & Andrea! I already took one of my inventions to market and sell it around the world. Now I’m trying to get a licensing deal for my earlier product idea which has been patented already. Hope this works!!

posted April 12, 2012 14:26 (
)
zabber's Avatargold
Andrea Zabinski
742,000
Insider Points

Avi, good luck, and welcome…stick around, your addiction is just starting! LOL

posted April 12, 2012 07:26 (
)
benco's Avatargold
Ben Cohen
40,000
Insider Points

Avi, welcome to the adventure. Good luck to you! Hatzlacha rabah!

posted April 12, 2012 07:22 (
)
brainstream's Avatargold
Todd Pagel
78,000
Insider Points

Good luck, Avi!!

posted April 12, 2012 07:21 (
)
statgear37's Avatargold
Avi Goldstein
40,000
Insider Points

Just posted my very first EN idea with this product search! Wish me luck!! Kinds nervous as you all seem so experienced in this! Good luck to you all as well! This looks like a great opportunity

posted April 12, 2012 07:06 (
)
brainstream's Avatargold
Todd Pagel
78,000
Insider Points

LOL Toni…Nothing “UGH” about any G5!! ;-) Good luck!

posted April 09, 2012 18:44 (
)
tonilrey's Avatarg8_badge
Toni Rey
336,000
Insider Points

Ugh…I’m still G5 on this one.

posted April 09, 2012 17:43 (
)



« Return to the forums index page