First time here? Sign up for a free account or log in

Forums » Live Product Search » Topic


What are my chances w/o a prototype?
jcepedar's Avatargold
Juan Cepeda-Rizo
jcepedar
Gold Member

I didn’t see this question posed on the FAQ section, but how does not having a prototype to affect the outcome of whether my idea is selected or not? Most of the LPS opportunities give you just a couple of months and I may not be able to spare the time and expense. I understand that “seeing is believing”, but it is much more reasonable for me to create a 3D rendering and even provide drawings and computer simulations.

Thanks,

Juan

posted October 22, 2009 12:05 (
)


cander09's Avatargold
Colonel Steve "Chris" Austin
cander09
Gold Member

Juan,

The 3D renderings, drawings and descriptions are fine. If you are presented to the sponsor, they may request a prototype from you to test your idea to see if the concept does what you say it will do.

Best wishes to you!

posted October 22, 2009 12:14 (
)
jcepedar's Avatargold
Juan Cepeda-Rizo
jcepedar
Gold Member

Chris,

Thanks. I’m guessing the sponsor doesn’t see the idea until the final step in the 7-step process?

posted October 22, 2009 12:21 (
)
cander09's Avatargold
Colonel Steve "Chris" Austin
cander09
Gold Member

Correct. Only the ideas that make it to 7 are presented to the search sponsor.

posted October 22, 2009 12:37 (
)
mger80's Avatargold
Margaret Pryor
mger80
Gold Member

Juan,

A prototype is not necessary. However, I think it is important. If you can make a proof of concept prototype, that would be very helpful to show that your product really does work as you thought. I can’t tell you how many of my ideas I have had to rethink when I sat down to make a prototype. Some of my simplest ideas didn’t work the way I thought they would and I have had to make changes to the design. Again, it’s not necessary, but it can help.

posted October 22, 2009 15:50 (
)
jcepedar's Avatargold
Juan Cepeda-Rizo
jcepedar
Gold Member

Margaret,

Thanks for the insight!

Juan

posted October 23, 2009 09:33 (
)
reneeyk's Avatargold
Renee Kennison
reneeyk
Gold Member

Margaret – I totally agree! The product I submitted in BB&B’s Women of Invention worked out great in my head, but I found problems when I drew it. Then when I made the prototype, I had to redesign as I went, as I realized what would work and what wouldn’t. What works on paper doesn’t always work in reality!

posted November 01, 2009 03:22 (
)
ivanna's Avatar
Irina Ivanna
ivanna

it’s like this: I come up with an idea and want to share it of course with my only auditorium – my husband. let say during dinner time I say, dear, i came up with an idea, it is a new version of a green sprinkler system using rain water. Rain water goes to a huge barrel. There is a hose on the bottom, there is a solar panel on top, there is a base with wheel and the timer. Husband looks puzzled; “Can you show me a drawing?”-he says. “Sure”, so I do the drawing, explaining once again. He says, “Hmm…what exactly these wheels are for? And what is that on top?” Knowing my husband’s ability to understand me not; I run to grab a box with our son’s clay, and as quickly as I can I build a something I call rought prototype. “A-a, alright, now I understand. Mm, I don’t think it’ll work, because…” etc.

posted November 01, 2009 12:52 (
)



« Return to the forums index page