First time here? Sign up for a free account or log in

Forums » Live Product Search » Topic


What are my chances w/o a prototype?
jcepedar's Avatar
Juan Cepeda-Rizo
jcepedar

I didn’t see this question posed on the FAQ section, but how does not having a prototype to affect the outcome of whether my idea is selected or not? Most of the LPS opportunities give you just a couple of months and I may not be able to spare the time and expense. I understand that “seeing is believing”, but it is much more reasonable for me to create a 3D rendering and even provide drawings and computer simulations.

Thanks,

Juan

posted October 22, 2009 12:05 (
)

Posting replies has been disabled
cander09's Avatarname search
Colonel Steve "Chris" Austin
cander09
256,250
Insider Points

Juan,

The 3D renderings, drawings and descriptions are fine. If you are presented to the sponsor, they may request a prototype from you to test your idea to see if the concept does what you say it will do.

Best wishes to you!

posted October 22, 2009 12:14 (
)
jcepedar's Avatar
Juan Cepeda-Rizo
jcepedar

Chris,

Thanks. I’m guessing the sponsor doesn’t see the idea until the final step in the 7-step process?

posted October 22, 2009 12:21 (
)
cander09's Avatarname search
Colonel Steve "Chris" Austin
cander09
256,250
Insider Points

Correct. Only the ideas that make it to 7 are presented to the search sponsor.

posted October 22, 2009 12:37 (
)
mger80's Avatargold
Margaret Pryor
mger80
215,500
Insider Points

Juan,

A prototype is not necessary. However, I think it is important. If you can make a proof of concept prototype, that would be very helpful to show that your product really does work as you thought. I can’t tell you how many of my ideas I have had to rethink when I sat down to make a prototype. Some of my simplest ideas didn’t work the way I thought they would and I have had to make changes to the design. Again, it’s not necessary, but it can help.

posted October 22, 2009 15:50 (
)
jcepedar's Avatar
Juan Cepeda-Rizo
jcepedar

Margaret,

Thanks for the insight!

Juan

posted October 23, 2009 09:33 (
)
reneeyk's Avatargold
Renee Kennison
reneeyk
52,500
Insider Points

Margaret – I totally agree! The product I submitted in BB&B’s Women of Invention worked out great in my head, but I found problems when I drew it. Then when I made the prototype, I had to redesign as I went, as I realized what would work and what wouldn’t. What works on paper doesn’t always work in reality!

posted November 01, 2009 03:22 (
)
ivanna's Avatar
Irina Ivanna
ivanna

it’s like this: I come up with an idea and want to share it of course with my only auditorium – my husband. let say during dinner time I say, dear, i came up with an idea, it is a new version of a green sprinkler system using rain water. Rain water goes to a huge barrel. There is a hose on the bottom, there is a solar panel on top, there is a base with wheel and the timer. Husband looks puzzled; “Can you show me a drawing?”-he says. “Sure”, so I do the drawing, explaining once again. He says, “Hmm…what exactly these wheels are for? And what is that on top?” Knowing my husband’s ability to understand me not; I run to grab a box with our son’s clay, and as quickly as I can I build a something I call rought prototype. “A-a, alright, now I understand. Mm, I don’t think it’ll work, because…” etc.

posted November 01, 2009 12:52 (
)
Posting replies has been disabled

« Return to the forums index page