First time here? Sign up for a free account or log in

Forums » Prototyping » Topic


I need some CAD help
mthomann's Avatargold
Dr. Mike Thomann
64,500
Insider Points

I need someone to help with CAD design of a fairly simple product. I already have a working prototype, but need some cad files, and some possible engineering improvmnt help.

posted May 07, 2008 11:39 (
)

Posting replies has been disabled
farling's Avatar
Toby Farling

My day job keeps me pretty busy but I have a seat of Unigraphics on my laptop from work and I could help if it is something that wouldn’t take very long to model.

posted June 10, 2008 19:03 (
)
makeworldbetter's Avataree_badge
Tim Chen

I use Blender 3D tool creates beautiful 3D design and it’s free; yet it’s not a CAD

posted June 10, 2008 16:31 (
)
pauly's Avatar
Paul Brunner

Thomas Clark,

I’m a CAD manager and I work with civil 3D. I have found it to be good and easy software to create designs from but I’ve been doing Cad for the past 14 years. It is expensive but if you’re anything like me than you’re constantly going back to school. There are student versions for a fraction of the cost.

Mike Thomann,

If you still need any CAD help I’ll offer my services.

posted June 10, 2008 15:07 (
)
designr's Avatar
Scott Doty

Paul,

Good point. That is definately something you want to check out before purchasing a CAD package as an inventor.

You can call the software company and ask if their package creates .stl or step files for rapid prototyping purposes. Then look at online forums to find out how well that feature works.

Well known packages such as Solidworks, Rhino, etc. all create good files for rapid prototyping. I imagine even some freeware 3d apps create these files these days, as it is such an important feature.

posted June 10, 2008 12:11 (
)
zosomojo's Avatar
Paul Wightman

Hello:

I’m having a lot of CAD stuff done, and the pro’s doing work for me all use SolidWorks. (3D viewing, and can rotate your 3D part on the screen any way you want).

If you ever want to use that CAD file to ‘print’ a 3D part, you’ll need to use a 3D drawing program, such as SolidWorks…
(that’s my understanding of it, anyway…)

~Paul

posted June 10, 2008 09:01 (
)
vitaminguy's Avatar
Rafael Avila

Thomas Clark,
There are two free CAD programs available that should do the trick for most moderate to intermediate applications. Alibre and CoCreate OneSpace. Both are offered by their makers as limited versions, with the hopes that you’ll like the software, and someday upgrade to the full featured version. As with any limite version, doing some things is a pain in the neck and takes a little longer than with the full version. After a little practice you will find you can do all the full featured stuff anyway, but it just takes more time. But if you’re on a low budget, these little gems are a lifesaver, as they can output in practically every format that machinists and rapid prototypers need.

posted June 10, 2008 00:36 (
)
paulz's Avatar
Paul Z

TAC, you should try a free downloadable software package called SketchUp (by Google I think). I haven’t used it myself but I’ve heard good things about it and it does 3d stuff.

posted June 09, 2008 19:20 (
)
tac's Avatar
Thomas Clark

All my experience is with the Autodesk products and the costs are in the thousands every year with a subscription. I could go on a jag about all the infuriating conversations I have had when I ask about the differences between Solid Works and Autocad Inventor,, If you ask a Solid Works user what the difference is you get the pat answer that “Solid Works is Three Dimensional and Autocad is not”, when I hear that I just change the subject because I know I am not going to get and usefull information.

But I digress, I have been looking at products like TurboCad and ViaCad because the are a fraction of the cost of the other products and I have a feeling it all I will really need for design parts for my inventions.

Rhino is cool, but more then I am willing to spend for now.

Does anyone know what IronCAD cost?

posted May 09, 2008 09:10 (
)
jimmybredskins's Avatar
jimmy burgess

Thomas

Sorry, my experience is all in “high end” software, none of which I have purchased myself. I couldn’t intelligently comment on any of the other software. AutoDesk does offer AutoCad LT ($1200) which is a “light” version of AutoCad, but it only has 2D capabilities.

Jimmy

posted May 09, 2008 05:35 (
)
designr's Avatar
Scott Doty

You should consider Rhino. It has some of the same commands as autocad and it’s very easy to learn.

Cost is about $900 though.

posted May 08, 2008 21:08 (
)
tac's Avatar
Thomas Clark

CAD people!
Jimmy, I am a daily cad user at work, but the package we use (Autodesk LandDevelopment/Civil 3-D) is not all that appropriate for modeling inventions. Further more, my ‘Barrowed’ copy of another title that I was learning to use seem to have a seriel number that has fallen from grace. So I am looking around for an “affordable” cad package for use at home. SOOOO I was wondering if you or anyone else had expereince with something like TurboCAD Delux,, ($75-$150). I was thinking about buying that one after reading stuff on the interweb.

My buddy sent me this link today, there is a free drawing tool from google, looks cool but I have not tried out yet. http://sketchup.google.com/product/gsu.html

posted May 08, 2008 15:53 (
)
jimmybredskins's Avatar
jimmy burgess

i’m certainly interesting in lending a hand. i’ve been utilizing AutoCad for 11 years now, doing 3D modeling for the past 8+ years.

let me know what sort of work you’re looking to have done and i’ll get on it it asap.

thanks,

jimmy

posted May 07, 2008 13:12 (
)
Posting replies has been disabled

« Return to the forums index page